‘My girlfriend is passive-aggressive and her anger is driving me away’

Everything I say gets distorted and thrown back at me

My girlfriend is passive-aggressive. We are in a long-distance relationship, and she had a string of horrible relationships before ours, as well as a more than rough childhood. With that in mind, I do not blame her for being as she is. But her comments have so much bite to them, they really hurt. And when I point this out to her she just says, "Oh, I'm just sharing my feelings with you. Isn't that what you want?"

I love her more than anybody I have ever loved in my life. Her children are the most amazing kids I have ever met and I want to be a part of their lives. But she is driving me away and she doesn't even know it. When she's angry, everything I say gets distorted and thrown back at me. Sometimes I slip and point this out to her, which only makes things worse. I can't talk to her about her anger because she always says, "I'm fine." I hate those two words. How do I get her to realise that she's passive-aggressive and seek help?

• If you would like to respond to this week's problem, please post your comment below.

When leaving a message on this page, please be sensitive to the fact that you are responding to a real person in the grip of a real-life dilemma, who wrote to Private Lives asking for help, and may well view your comments here. Please consider especially how your words or the tone of your message could be perceived by someone in this situation, and be aware that comments which appear to be disruptive or disrespectful to the individual concerned will be removed.

• If you would like fellow readers to respond to a dilemma of yours, send us an outline of the situation of around 150 words. For advice from Pamela Stephenson Connolly on sexual matters, send us a brief description of your concerns.

• All correspondence should reach us by Wednesday morning. Email: private.lives@guardian.co.uk (please don't send attachments)


guardian.co.uk © 2012 Guardian News and Media Limited or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved. | Use of this content is subject to our Terms & Conditions | More Feeds

My partner says I am too loud in bed

There's nothing wrong with you, but you may want to explore some options that work for both of you

I have fantastic sex with a new partner and I have orgasms every time, but he says I make too much noise. He says I sound like I'm being murdered and it's "distracting". He jokingly mentioned that maybe I should have counselling for the problem. I've never thought that my noise in the bedroom was a problem before, but I've never had such great sex in my life. I have been using a pillow over my head, but I find it suffocating. Is there any underlying psychological issue that might affect the level of noise one makes? Previously, I lived a sexless life for 10 years. My new partner is really caring and I wouldn't want to put him off by screaming my head off every time I climax.

I doubt there's anything wrong with you. You're just thoroughly enjoying yourself, and you can let go in a way that would be envied by many others. Given your long period of abstinence, it's particularly understandable that you'd want to savour this opportunity to finally be satisfied. I would caution you to stop using the pillow, because that will restrict your breathing, which could lead to other problems. Many people don't mind a noisy partner, but since he is distracted, might I suggest some lateral thinking, such as earplugs for him and perhaps a darkened room? If he's concerned that others might hear you, try to be creative about soundproofing your environment (you could even seek some wide, open spaces!). It may be that your partner's more attuned to visual, auditory or kinesthetic senses rather than sound, and needs silence to enjoy his particular style of sensuality. Negotiate something that works for both of you.

• Pamela Stephenson Connolly is a clinical psychologist and psychotherapist who specialises in treating sexual disorders.

•Send your problem to private.lives@guardian.co.uk


guardian.co.uk © 2012 Guardian News and Media Limited or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved. | Use of this content is subject to our Terms & Conditions | More Feeds

Dear Mariella: I’m angry and frustrated with my husband. I wonder if going to church is the answer

A mother who works 60 hours a week wonders if going to church could help her cope with the daily frustrations of life. Mariella Frostrup tells her she must find a way to let off steam

The dilemma I feel angry a lot at the moment – I'm taking it out on my husband, and because my two-year-old is inseparable from him I'm worried I'm also hurting him when I head for the front door. I'm so frustrated. I'm the main breadwinner and I work 60 hours a week while my husband and mother-in-law look after our children. It's the best-case scenario, but it drives me mad. My husband constantly whines about how tired he is from his 27-hour working week. When I'm at home I'm in primary care of the children. I would find the sick feminist joke that is my life funny and enjoyable if I was appreciated, but I'm not remotely. I have my character assassinated on a daily basis. Do you think church is the answer? I don't believe in God, but all that singing and being grateful has to help, surely?


Mariella replies It surely has. Who'd have thought that at this point in the 21st century, in an increasingly secular society, we'd need God's house more than ever? The unfairness of your situation is writ large for all to see so I'll refrain from my customary feminist rant. Where should those in need turn? Facebook? Mumsnet? The songs and solace offered by the church have taken on a compelling new allure. Led by kindly, cuddly, old-world characters like Rowan Williams who you suspect, given 10 minutes audience, would really understand your problems, the church is far more appealing in a crisis than social services, not least because you don't need to go through a complex automated phone service to reach a human being.

Embracing religion is one of the few guaranteed ways of joining a real- life community, carving out a blame-free 90 minutes a week for yourself against the backdrop of Mass, and experiencing a cathartic blast of exuberance during hymn singing. I'm more naturally tilted towards Richard Dawkins and the late Christopher Hitchens's atheism, but surely even they would appreciate that desperate times lead to inexplicable choices?

Nobody understands what you are going through better than the many millions of other women going through exactly the same thing. Your letter offers further proof of the extent to which we're all struggling to marry post-feminist expectations with our primitive instincts in an era where work is no longer a choice but a necessity for all but the supremely privileged or utterly selfless. Only a truly desperate creature would contemplate embracing a religion they don't believe in just to get some respite from their daily life.

Netball clubs, zumba classes and book clubs are a less philosophically taxing but nicely diverting option. Joining female contemporaries in any group activity on a regular basis is a surefire way to stop my head exploding, and it sounds like you too need to release some of that pent-up pressure. Steam disposal is a survival secret men have pursued for centuries – hence the endless array of essential extracurricular activities they have to indulge in, from football matches to DIY, cycling to engine assembly.

Rather than joining the masses dashing from one megastore to the next, spending money they don't have on things they don't need, where better to spend leisure time than in the house of the Lord? Mother-in-law and partner will be banished to the back of your brain as you belt out "Jerusalem" and count your blessings. Let's bring back poetry clubs and knitting circles, village bakes and children's Sunday clubs, too. I'd nod in acquiescence to a mythical life in the hereafter in return for some peace and quiet in the here and now. It's either that or join the WI.

The Thatcher fantasy has become our reality. Community is a thing of the past, social networks are increasingly in cyberspace, not outside your front door, and we're all being worn down by the death throes of our once-great civilisation. The good news is that though work adds an extra eight hours to your already packed day, it also gives you an opportunity to talk to people who aren't asking where they've left their socks and what's for supper. In the bosom of the working world you probably thought your husband would wait on you hand and foot in gratitude for your efforts. Was that a derisive snort I just heard from the entire female population? Any word that prefixes "holidays", unless it's "working", creates an oxymoron for hard-pressed mothers. I wish I had a magic answer, mainly selfishly, because my own life would be so vastly improved. But I don't. Church seems as good a place as any to start your search for salvation!


If you have a dilemma, send a brief email to mariella.frostrup@observer.co.uk. To have your say on this week's column, go to guardian.co.uk/dearmariella. Follow Mariella on Twitter @mariellaf1


guardian.co.uk © 2012 Guardian News and Media Limited or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved. | Use of this content is subject to our Terms & Conditions | More Feeds

Diary of a separation

A chilly realisation that the boiler has died

I have a theory that you're not really an adult until you've experienced boiler bereavement. There's denial ("It'll just be the pilot light, I just need to press this button a few times"), anger (as the landlord screens your frantic calls), bargaining (with a succession of plumbers you find in the Yellow Pages whose names all begin with AAAA), depression (no one will come out until next week) and finally acceptance (of call-out charges hovering around £200 per half hour or part thereof). Most importantly, there's the realisation that your home isn't the impregnable fortress you had complacently assumed it was.

My boiler died this week. It isn't my first broken boiler, but it's the first one I'm solely responsible for. I've been half expecting it – there's been some worrying business with the thermostat – but it hits me hard ... waking up to a suspicious chill, running the hot tap in vain, hoping I'm wrong. I try not to panic: first, I go down to the basement to stare at it, hoping for a miracle.

The boiler is gigantic and off-putting, with five enormous pipes emerging from its squat grey body at improbable angles. I open the front door, experimentally, and look for a pilot light button to press, but there's nothing, just a sort of rusty screw, and a butch-looking gauge. I'm lost. The thermostat, with its yellowing card of oblique instructions in my landlady's spiky handwriting, is bad enough. It whirrs and clicks ominously in the evenings. I give up and ring my landlady.

"What have you done to it?" she says, instantly on the offensive.

"Nothing!" I protest. "It just stopped working overnight, honestly."

There's a chilly pause. She has a knack of making me feel guilty when I haven't done anything wrong, which must be useful in her occupation. "Have you touched the thermostat?"

"No!" I lie, palms slightly sweaty.

Grudgingly, she agrees to try to arrange an engineer, but not today, and probably not tomorrow. I hang up feeling furiously impotent and cast around for a solution. I could call my neighbour. He's quite handy – he's fixed my Wi-Fi and put up shelves for me in the past – but he's also a total chancer. There will be some outlandish reason why I need to lend him a hundred quid and if I'm really unlucky, he'll show me his awful drawings of cars again.

Or maybe I should try to get it fixed myself? The thought fills me with gloom (they'll lie to me and take all my money, and my landlady will never pay me back), but at least I'll be taking charge of my own heating destiny. I text a friend to ask if she knows a reliable plumber. "Would you like John to come and have a look?" she texts back. John is her husband. "He's pretty good at that kind of thing."

"Thank you!" I text back, filled with relief. "That would be wonderful."

X is pretty good at this kind of thing too. One of the first things he ever did for me was fix my television and then, as now, I was filled with admiration for his nonchalant techno-brilliance. How do people know this stuff? He called earlier about a forgotten video game, and hearing the edge in my voice, asked what was wrong.

"The boiler's dead."

"Oh no, I'm sorry."

I could feel my composure slipping.

"And my landlady is being evil."

"If you need me ..."

"Thanks." I can't though, can I? It's up to me now.

Actually, it's up to John, who comes round a few hours later with his toolbox, and disappears downstairs, refusing cups of tea. After 20 anxious minutes, he shouts up to tell me to feel the radiator and, sure enough, it's warming, slowly. He comes back upstairs, wiping his hands on a piece of kitchen roll. "Oh, thank you so much, John – you're a lifesaver."

"No problem. I don't know how long it'll last though."

Which is exactly what I expected to hear.


guardian.co.uk © 2012 Guardian News and Media Limited or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved. | Use of this content is subject to our Terms & Conditions | More Feeds